Dog Behaviour

Taking bone from dog

Vets are asked every day how to help with dog behaviour issues. Behaviour problems are the biggest health problem facing dogs and their owners. These problems tarnish the relationship with your dog and often indicate that a pet is living a relatively unhappy life. The decision to put a dog to sleep because of a behaviour problem is the hardest one any pet owner has to make. But sometimes there is no option – particularly when a dog has bitten.

One of the most common dog myths I see continued is the dominance theory. So many new pet owners proudly declare that they take their dog’s bones and food away while they are eating – just to show them who’s boss. They believe that by demonstrating dominance over their dog that their dog will submit to them and they will all live happily ever after.

But it’s not that simple.

A dominance relationship is not a hard and fast vertical ladder with “boss” on the top rung and “minions” on the lower. This visual makes it seem logical, that all members of the lower rungs are hell bent on climbing the ladder and that you have to keep knocking them down if you want to stay on top.

But true dog and family relationships are just not like that.

What are Dominance Relationships Actually Like

Dominance relationships are always dynamic and relative to the situation at any given time. One dog may be “dominant” when it comes to a favourite toy and will put up a good fight to anyone who tries to take it away from them.   Another dog may be dominant when it comes to choosing a sleeping position.  And yet another dog may be dominant in an interaction when it comes to food.


Dogs sleeping on bed


The dominance relationship depends on the members present and the situation or the resource being considered at that time.

It depends on just how much each dog wants that thing!

So, in the case of removing the bone from the dog happily chewing it. You may find that the first few times this works OK as your dog sits up and wonders why you are stealing their food.  But then comes the moment when they think “Hang on, that’s mine and I really want it”.  The only way they have to fight for it is to growl and bite.


Dog with bone showing aggression

And suddenly you’ve got a food aggressive dog that has learnt accurately that the luxury of food can be taken away from them and that they may miss out. They are then more likely to be anxious around food and be protective. We call this resource guarding.

What Should You Do Instead

Good leadership does not require you to bully your dog into submission. It is leading by example. You already decide what, when and where to feed your dog. They already know you are the leader here. If you choose to offer your dog a meal, don’t renege on the deal and steal it back from them. Don’t make them fear that they have to fight for it. You are setting them up for a behavioural failure.

Respect them by allowing them to eat in peace and be secure in the knowledge that their bone or food is theirs, they don’t have to fear losing it. Good leadership is providing your family with the resources they need with enough for everybody. Dogs just need a stable leader to provide food, shelter, comfort, love. This is good leadership in the eyes of a dog and if you provide this – they will follow you anywhere.

Bentons Road Vet combining Natural Health & Modern Medicine